Joe Biden and Donald Trump Getty Images/Salon
Progressives are raising alarm over new poll results from CBS News out Tuesday, which suggest the Democratic Party’s courting of moderate so-called “Biden Republicans” while sidelining popular progressive proposals and voices has not so far resulted in a groundswell of support for Democratic presidential nominee Joe Biden from disaffected GOP voters.
In a poll taken between August 20 and 22, after the Democratic National Convention wrapped up last week, CBS found that just 5% of self-identified Republicans said they plan to vote for Biden in the November election; 93% said they were planning to vote for President Donald Trump.
The president also led by 10 percentage points among Independent voters, who make up a plurality of U.S. voters.
Justice Democrats spokesperson Waleed Shahid tweeted that the poll showed an “interesting dynamic” following a national convention at which the party gave more speaking time to anti-Trump Republicans including former Ohio Gov. John Kasich and former Secretary of State Colin Powell than they did to popular progressive Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-N.Y.), as well as largely ignoring a number of key progressive policy proposals.
An interesting dynamic in latest CBS poll:
Only 5% of Republicans say they’re voting for Joe Biden.
Right now that’s lower than the 8% of Republicans who voted for Obama in 2008, 6% of Republicans who voted for Obama in 2012, and 7% of Republicans who voted for Hillary Clinton. pic.twitter.com/gIblOm1kJB
— Waleed Shahid (@_waleedshahid) August 25, 2020
Biden’s support within the GOP is now lower than the number of Republicans who voted for Hillary Clinton in 2016, according to the CBS poll, as well as those who voted for former President Barack Obama in 2008 and 2012.
CBS also asked moderates and conservatives if they would “ever consider voting for Joe Biden.” Just 7% of moderates and 4% of conservatives said yes, while 77% and 95%, respectively, replied, “No, I never would.”
Journalist David Sirota, who served as a speechwriter and adviser for Sen. Bernie Sanders’ 2020 presidential campaign, expressed relief that Biden maintained an overall lead in the poll, with 52% of respondents saying they planned to vote for the former vice president and 42% reporting they would vote for Trump if the election were held right now.
But he noted Trump’s “disturbingly big lead among Independents” and called on the party to rely not on support from anti-Trump Republicans and Independents but rather to focus on appealing to Democratic voters, including those who may not ordinarily vote.
“Defeating Trump is all about Democratic turnout,” tweeted Sirota. “Biden’s support among Independents in this new CBS poll [is] not good. That’s really concerning.”
Three things stand out in this new CBS poll:
1. Biden has a solid overall lead (good!)
2. Trump has a disturbingly big lead among independents (bad!)
3. There's basically no such thing as a Biden Republican, which means defeating Trump is all about Dem turnout. pic.twitter.com/Ua8cTulpao
— David Sirota (@davidsirota) August 24, 2020
The Democratic Party garnered criticism from progressives last week for its centrist messaging at the convention. In the final party platform, the Democratic National Committee quietly removed an amendment calling for an end to federal subsidies for fossil fuel companies, resulting in a climate platform further to the right than the ones both Biden and vice presidential candidate Kamala Harris ran on during the Democratic primary.
The convention left Ocasio-Cortez with the impression that as a “young, progressive Latina…I was not the target audience of this convention. The target audience for this convention was white moderates who aren’t sure who they’re voting for in November.”
“I think we could have done more to rally turnout enthusiasm from our party’s base,” the congresswoman wrote on Instagram after the convention.
Despite the popularity of Medicare for All among Democrats and Independents—who support the proposal at a rate of 75% and 52%, respectively, according to a Morning Consult/Politico poll taken in April—the policy is mentioned in the Democratic platform only once, with the DNC conceding that it “welcomes advocates” who support Medicare for All.
The corporate media encouraged the Democrats to reject the party’s so-called “left-leaning brand,” with the New York Times suggesting Biden “inspire defections from college-educated suburban voters—especially women—who had been core Republican voters for decades and offer conservative-leaning voters a sober, reassuring alternative to a chaotic president” while focusing on a vague set of “kitchen table issues”—not including, ostensibly, the struggles the for-profit healthcare industry creates for American families and the climate crisis, which a rising number of Americans are concerned about, according to a recent Stanford University study.
As Ari Paul wrote at Common Dreams on Tuesday, other outlets have praised the Democrats in recent days for steering “clear of the most far-reaching progressive demands” and building “a centrist coalition in favor of political sanity.”
But the recent CBS poll revealed an error in the Democratic establishment’s judgement, suggested Nina Turner, who served as national co-chair for Sen. Bernie Sanders’ 2020 presidential campaign.
So much for going all out to get Republicans and shunning progressives🤦🏾♀️🤷🏾♀️😒
— Nina Turner (@ninaturner) August 25, 2020
At Common Dreams on Tuesday, Patriotic Millionaires board chair Morris Pearl wrote that while the Democratic Party has thus far “failed to meet the 2020 moment…with the election on the horizon, there’s still time to course-correct.”
“Reversing some of the most egregious legislation of the Trump administration, like the 2017 tax cuts that amounted to a $1.7 trillion giveaway to the top one percent, is a start,” wrote Pearl. “And the Democratic platform endorses this. But simply repealing whatever Trump has done is not a positive vision for the future. If ever there was a time to get behind big, bold economic policy ideas like the Green New Deal or a wealth tax, now is the time.”